A leaking tank or a smell of gas comes first
If water is pooling around the base of the tank, find the cold water valve on the pipe at the top of the heater and turn it clockwise until it stops. If it will not turn, shut the water off at the valve beside the pressure tank. That stops water to the whole house. For an electric heater, switch off its breaker at the panel. For a gas heater, turn the gas control to off. Then keep water use low until someone has looked at it.
If you smell gas near the heater, do not switch lights or appliances on or off. Leave the house and call your gas supplier's emergency line from outside. Do not go back in to shut anything off. A gas smell, a tank leaking steadily or water spreading toward the electrical panel is an emergency call.
A slow drip from the relief valve on the side of the tank is a different matter. That valve opens when the temperature or pressure inside climbs too high. Never cap or plug it. Put a pail under the discharge pipe and call. The drip is a sign of a problem with the thermostat or the pressure in the system, and in a house on a well that can mean the pressure tank.
No hot water usually has a cause you can find
On an electric tank, no hot water at all usually means a tripped breaker, a failed element or a faulty thermostat. Reset the breaker once. If it trips again, leave it off. If hot water runs out much sooner than it used to, the lower element has often failed, so only the top of the tank is heating. On a gas tank, look through the small window near the bottom to see whether the pilot is lit. If it is out and you are comfortable following the relighting steps on the label, you can try once. If it goes out again, stop there.
A house on a well has one more thing to check before the water heater: whether the cold water is normal. If the cold taps are weak too, the problem is upstream, at the well pump, the pressure switch or the pressure tank, and no water heater can make up for that. A power cut stops the well pump as well, so even a gas heater only delivers what is left in the pressure tank.
A tankless heater that cuts out in the middle of a shower is often reacting to low flow. It needs a minimum flow before it will fire. Pressure swings as a well pump cycles on and off can take the flow below that minimum, and so can a clogged inlet screen.
Smelly, rusty or noisy hot water points to the tank or the well
Hot water that smells of rotten eggs, while the cold water does not, is common in houses on a well. Bacteria in the well water react with the metal rod inside the tank, called the anode, and give off a gas that causes the smell. It is unpleasant but not an emergency. A different type of anode rod often helps. If the cold water smells too, have the well itself looked at.
Rusty hot water can mean the tank lining has started to fail. In the older houses around Peel Street West and Church Street, and in the houses along Wellington Road 7 and Wellington Road 17 that still have galvanized steel lines, the rust may come from the pipe rather than the tank. Run a cold tap and then a hot one. If only the hot water is brown, the tank is the likely source.
Popping or rumbling while the tank heats comes from sediment on the bottom. Well water can carry fine sand and silt, which settles in the tank over time. Flushing can help a tank that is otherwise sound. A tank that is already leaking from its seams cannot be repaired, only replaced.
Tank or tankless depends on the well, the household and the fuel
A tank heater stores hot water and is forgiving. It copes with modest flow and keeps a supply on hand while the well pump cycles. A tankless heater heats water as it passes through, so it does not run out, but it needs steady flow and clean water. On a well, that often means fitting a sediment filter ahead of it. A gas tankless unit needs its own venting. An electric tankless unit draws heavily on the electrical panel, which matters in an older house.
A new heater should be sized to the people in the house, the way they use water and what your well and pressure tank can deliver, not just to the label on the old heater. Gas work is performed by TSSA-certified gas technicians, as Ontario's rules for gas water heaters require. For a longer comparison, read tank or tankless: which water heater suits a house on a well.
Hot water at the shower and tub is limited to 49 °C
Ontario's Building Code limits water coming out of a shower head or into a bathtub to 49 °C. The limit is there to prevent scalds, because young children and older adults burn quickly in water hotter than that. The tank itself is often kept hotter so bacteria do not grow in the stored water. A mixing valve or a pressure-balancing shower valve then brings the temperature down at the fixture.
If your shower runs hotter than you would like, or turns hot when someone flushes a toilet, that can be fixed. A plumber can measure the temperature at the tap and adjust or fit the right valve.
A water heater visit starts with questions, then tests
The plumber starts with questions you can already partly answer. Is there any hot water? Is the cold water normal? Is anything leaking? Then they check the power or gas supply, the elements or burner, the thermostat, the relief valve and the pressure coming from the well. You get a written price for the repair or replacement and approve it before any part is fitted. If a repair is not worth doing on an ageing tank, the plumber says so and explains why.
If the tank is replaced, the old one is drained outdoors where possible, rather than emptying a full tank of silty water into a drain that runs to the septic tank. Where a new heater joins old galvanized pipe, the right fittings are used so the two metals do not corrode each other. Moving a heater, changing the piping or converting to tankless can need a permit. The municipal building department decides, and you will know before work starts whether one applies. Work is performed by licensed plumbers (306A Certificate of Qualification). For other faults in the water lines, see plumbing repairs, or ask for a written price.
